Work/Life Balance? Not if the Supreme Court has any say...

In this day and age, many companies tout that they encourage their employees to achieve work/life balance.  They go so far as to have their employees complete questionnaires so that they can make Fortune Magazine's list of 100 Best Companies to Work For or Working Mother Magazine's 100 Best Companies.  In August 2011, U.S. District Judge Loretta Preska slammed the door on the notion that women can work, raise children, and expect equal treatment.

From Ms Magazine Blog by Nanette Fondas:

I’m referring to Wednesday’s court decision in which  U.S. District Judge Loretta Preska dismissed a class-action discrimination suit by the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission against financial services corporation Bloomberg L.P. Preska ruled that there was not sufficient statistical evidence that Bloomberg women employees who became pregnant between 2002 and 2009 were later demoted or paid less than workers who took other types of leaves.

Working moms just can’t get a break. First the Supreme Court ruled in the Wal-Mart class-action suit that the number of women alleging discrimination was too big. Now a U.S. District Court in Manhattan rules that the group of Bloomberg claimants was too small to prove that pregnancy discrimination was “standard operating procedure.”

On dismissing the lawsuit, Judge Preska waded into the work-life debate when she quoted Jack Welch (former chief executive of G.E.) saying, “There’s no such thing as work-life balance. There are work-life choices, and you make them, and they have consequences.” In other words, people who decide to spend time giving birth, recovering and breastfeeding might not advance as quickly as the guy who doesn’t stop to breathe.

Did she say “Jack Welch”? Yes, he was a business icon at one time. His leadership was heralded at Harvard Business School in the early ’80s. But his reign in the world of influential ideas was then and this is now. Right now the U.S. faces global competition in the supply of manufacturing and service products on a scale and scope we’ve not seen before. We can no longer afford to dismiss half of our human resource capital because it happens to be female and sometimes bear children. G.E., Bloomberg, Wal-Mart and other giants need involved and committed women employees (even after they become mothers, no less), to remain competitive. This is not a new idea, but the Bloomberg case’s reasoning and citing of a business dinosaur reminds us that business culture still has far to develop.

As a society, we don’t want organizations filled with only guys (and gals) who don’t stop to breathe. Judge Preska said, “The law does not require companies to ignore or stop valuing ultimate dedication, however unhealthy that may be for family life.”  The “law” does not require this of companies, but we as workers, consumers and citizens need to require it. If this is all to be left to the free market, as the ruling promotes, then let’s not shop and work at places that are hostile to working women, babies and families. For now, this may be the way to nudge business toward more social responsibility, particularly making  workplaces more family friendly. Business firms, too, have to see that work-life choices have consequences.

ysl replica handbags ysl replica handbags replica handbags replica handbags replica handbags louis vuitton replica handbags hermes replica handbags ysl replica handbags ysl replica handbags Hermes replica handbags mulberry replica handbags hermes replica handbags replica handbags replica handbags louis vuitton replica handbags louis vuitton replica handbags Hermes replica handbags Hermes replica handbags celine replica handbags Hermes replica handbags mulberry replica handbags Hermes replica handbags mulberry replica handbags 70-486 70-410 810-420 microsoft 70-411 70-229 820-421 Cisco microsoft 70-347 70-480 pass 70-162 70-177 exam 70-462 exam Microsoft 70-243 70-271 pass 70-414 pass 70-461 70-417 C_TAW12_731 400-101 70-483 pass 70-412 cisco 100-101 200-120 400-101 exam cisco 700-104 Cisco 810-420 070-089 dumps 070-121 070-122 exam Cisco 350-029 70-410 exam microsoft 70-480 70-483 pass 70-412 300-209 miscrosoft 70-341 microsoft MB2-703 70-413 pass MB2-701 exam 070-292 exam microsoft 070-294 Cisco 640-554 exam
mulberry replica handbags louis vuitton replica handbags burberry replica handbags mulberry replica handbags replica handbags replica handbags replica handbags replica handbags hermes replica handbags replica handbags replica handbags hermes replica handbags louis vuitton replica handbags louis vuitton replica handbags louis vuitton replica handbags louis vuitton replica handbags replica handbags louis vuitton replica handbags hermes replica handbags louis vuitton replica handbags louis vuitton replica handbags louis vuitton replica handbags replica handbags louis vuitton replica handbags hermes replica handbags fendi replica handbags replica handbags fendi replica handbags replica handbags queenbag.co replica handbags replica handbags replica handbags replica handbags louis vuitton replica handbags Microsoft 70-415 dumps 650-298 MB4-534 Cisco 646-058 exam 70-557 MB3-462 Microsoft 70-582 exam 070-623 650-575 Cisco 642-279 exam 70-573 070-686 Microsoft MB6-508 dumps 070-639 646-222 Microsoft 070-659 exam 70-121 650-178 646-361 Cisco 646-203 exam MB3-215 642-982 Microsoft 74-322 exam 640-878 700-505 Microsoft MB5-198 dumps 642-144 070-646 MB7-514 70-620 Cisco 642-426 exam 70-123 Cisco 640-916 dumps MB3-700 642-545 Cisco 640-554 exam 70-625 74-343 Microsoft 70-455 exam 070-621 650-293 Microsoft MB7-225 dumps 70-222 MB5-855 070-403 Cisco 700-701 exam MB2-186 070-227 Microsoft MB7-839 exam 70-448 Cisco 650-669 exam 70-178 70-579 Microsoft 77-885 exam 070-526 Microsoft 70-684 dumps 70-410 Microsoft 074-132 dumps MB3-465 Cisco 642-091 exam

Have a Comment?

Comment:




User Comments